In e-commerce, an abandoned cart email is a strategic tool used to re-engage customers who leave a website without completing their purchase. At its core, the purpose is clear: to recover lost sales. However, there’s an ongoing debate on how these emails should be classified. Are abandoned cart emails transactional—meant solely to serve a function within a sale—or do they tread into marketing territory, blending recovery with promotional elements? Understanding the distinction is essential for businesses, as it affects not only the effectiveness of these emails but also compliance with privacy laws and customer trust.

What Are Abandoned Cart Emails?

Abandoned cart emails are follow-up messages sent to potential customers who leave items in their online shopping cart without purchasing. These emails gently remind the customer of their pending items, encouraging them to return and complete their transaction. For businesses, these emails serve a vital role in salvaging sales that may otherwise be lost, and for customers, they can be helpful nudges about products they showed interest in.

Abandoned cart emails have a high engagement rate, as they target customers who are already in the purchase funnel. However, whether these emails are viewed as transactional or marketing content impacts how recipients perceive them and  the legal requirements surrounding them.

What Classifies an Email as Transactional?

Transactional emails, in email marketing, are defined by their primary purpose: facilitating an agreed-upon transaction or relationship. These emails deliver essential information to the recipient, such as order confirmations, shipping notifications, and password reset requests. Because their purpose is functional rather than promotional, transactional emails do not typically require explicit consent from recipients. According to the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003, emails that merely provide transactional or relationship information—such as a receipt or an account status update—are not subject to stringent marketing regulations like opt-out provisions. This distinction helps us better understand the role of different types of emails and their impact on customers.

Are Abandoned Cart Emails Marketing or Transactional?

The classification of abandoned cart emails depends on their content. At their core, these emails are reminders of pending transactions—hence, a strong case for being transactional. Yet, many businesses enhance these emails with promotional elements such as discounts or product suggestions, transforming them into marketing content.

Abandoned Cart Emails as Transactional

When abandoned cart emails solely remind customers of items left in their cart without any additional marketing offers, they are largely considered transactional. In this format, they focus purely on completing an existing transaction, acting as a gentle nudge for the customer to pick up where they left off. For example, a straightforward email listing the items in a cart with a link back to the cart is transactional by nature. By keeping content free from promotional language or incentives, businesses can often send these emails without needing explicit user consent, as these emails are part of the customer service journey.

Example of a Transactional Abandoned Cart Email:

Subject Line: “You Left Something Behind!”

Email Content:

Hi [Customer Name],
It looks like you left a few items in your cart. We’re holding them for you, so there’s still time to complete your purchase!

Items in Your Cart

• [Item 1 – Name, Image, Price]
• [Item 2 – Name, Image, Price]

Click [here] to return to your cart and check out.

Thanks for shopping with us!

In this example, the email only lists the items left in the cart with a straightforward link to complete the purchase. There are no discounts, upsells, or urgency tactics, making it a purely transactional email aimed at facilitating the completion of the order without crossing into marketing territory.

Abandoned Cart Emails as Marketing

When businesses introduce discounts, free shipping offers, or recommended products in abandoned cart emails, these messages shift into the marketing category. This strategic shift is designed to incentivize the purchase and enhance the email’s appeal, making it a promotional tool rather than a mere reminder. However, this transition comes with stricter legal obligations. In the EU, for instance, GDPR mandates that such emails require opt-in consent if they contain marketing content, as they are no longer solely transactional. For example, an email offering a 10% discount on cart items crosses into marketing territory and is subject to privacy laws and opt-in requirements, as it actively encourages purchasing behavior beyond the initial abandoned cart.

Example of a Marketing Abandoned Cart Email:

Subject Line: “Don’t Miss Out! Complete Your Order and Save 10%!”

Email Content:

Hi [Customer Name],
We noticed you left these items in your cart. Come back and complete your purchase with an exclusive 10% discount!

Items in Your Cart

• [Item 1 – Name, Image, Price]
• [Item 2 – Name, Image, Price]

Use code SAVE10 at checkout to get your discount. Plus, free shipping on orders over $50!

Hurry—your items are going fast!

Click [here] to return to your cart and complete your order.

This version includes a discount code and a free shipping offer, clearly moving into marketing territory. The urgency created by phrases like “hurry” and “your items are going fast” reinforces the promotional aim of the email, which seeks to actively drive conversions with incentives.

Legal Considerations for Abandoned Cart Emails

When sending abandoned cart emails in the U.S., businesses must comply with a range of privacy laws and email regulations to avoid penalties and ensure ethical marketing practices. Two key laws in the U.S. are the CAN-SPAM Act and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which has been further enhanced by the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA). These regulations focus on transparency, user consent, and providing clear options for opting out of communications, which is especially important when the email content shifts from transactional to marketing.

CAN-SPAM Act (U.S.)

The CAN-SPAM Act sets the standard for commercial emails in the U.S. and applies to all types of commercial messages, including marketing-oriented abandoned cart emails. The law requires businesses to:

1. Avoid Deceptive Subject Lines and Content: The subject line must accurately reflect the content of the email. This rule applies specifically to marketing abandoned cart emails that include promotional offers or incentives. If an email offers a discount on cart items, the subject line must not misleadingly imply it’s a service reminder or purely transactional.
2. Provide a Clear Opt-Out Mechanism: All commercial emails, including abandoned cart emails that include marketing content, must provide recipients with an easy and prominent method to opt out of future emails. This opt-out option must be functional for at least 30 days after the email is sent, and businesses must process opt-out requests within 10 business days. For transactional emails (those purely reminding customers to complete a pending transaction), while the law is more lenient, including an opt-out link is a best practice to maintain transparency.
3. Accurate “From” Information: The “From,” “To,” and “Reply-To” fields, along with routing information, must accurately identify the business or entity responsible for sending the email. This transparency is especially crucial in abandoned cart emails, whether they are transactional or marketing, to avoid misleading customers about the sender.
4. Physical Address Requirement: Every email must include the sender’s valid physical postal address. For B2B marketers, especially those leveraging automation for large-scale campaigns, ensuring this address is correct is crucial to maintaining CAN-SPAM compliance.

Relevance to Abandoned Cart Emails:

• Transactional Abandoned Cart Emails: While these may not be subject to all the strict guidelines of CAN-SPAM regarding opt-in consent, they must still comply with rules on truthful content, “From” information, and providing an opt-out mechanism to avoid misclassification.
• Marketing Abandoned Cart Emails: If the email includes any promotional content (e.g., a discount, upsell products), it is classified as marketing and must follow all CAN-SPAM provisions. Failure to comply can lead to penalties of up to $51,744 per violation, making adherence critical for businesses scaling their email marketing efforts.

CCPA/CPRA (California)

The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and its amendment, the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA), are comprehensive data privacy laws that govern how businesses collect, store, and use personal data from California residents. While not solely focused on email marketing, these laws impact how businesses handle email addresses and other personal information in the context of abandoned cart emails.

1. Right to Opt-Out of Marketing Communications: Under CCPA/CPRA, consumers have the right to opt out of the sale or sharing of their personal information, which includes their email addresses. If abandoned cart emails contain marketing content (such as discounts or promotions), businesses must honor any opt-out requests promptly and ensure that customers are aware of their rights to opt out of future communications.
2. Disclosure Requirements: Businesses are required to disclose how they intend to use customer data, including email addresses collected during the checkout process. This information should be made clear in the company’s privacy policy, particularly if abandoned cart emails are used to re-engage customers. The CCPA mandates that businesses inform customers at the point of collection how their data will be used, which includes any potential marketing follow-ups.
3. Data Deletion Requests: Consumers in California can request the deletion of their personal data, including email addresses. For abandoned cart emails, this means if a customer requests data deletion, the business must ensure that no further communications, whether transactional or marketing, are sent unless they relate directly to a pending transaction. This is a crucial consideration when managing customer databases, especially for businesses with significant e-commerce operations.

Relevance to Abandoned Cart Emails:

• Transactional Abandoned Cart Emails: Even when emails are purely transactional, CCPA/CPRA still applies if the customer data is used for tracking or if the business operates in California. Though opt-in consent for transactional emails is not required, businesses must still offer transparency about data collection and provide opt-out options.
• Marketing Abandoned Cart Emails: Including promotional content in these emails requires adherence to CCPA/CPRA’s marketing regulations. This means ensuring that customers are informed about the potential use of their data for marketing purposes and have clear options to opt out or delete their data.

Best Practices for Structuring Abandoned Cart Emails

To ensure both compliance and effectiveness, structuring abandoned cart emails should balance transactional reminders with compelling, user-centric design. Here are key practices:

• Use Concise, Descriptive Subject Lines: Ensure the subject line accurately represents the email’s content, maintaining a professional tone without being misleading.
• Include Personalization: Address customers by name or reference specific cart items to establish a direct connection and increase re-engagement potential.
• Provide Clear Calls to Action (CTA): Use a single, prominent CTA to direct customers back to their cart, enhancing clarity and reducing decision friction.
• Offer Product Recommendations (If Appropriate): Suggest similar items or upsells sparingly, particularly in transactional emails, to maintain compliance.
• Incorporate Social Proof or Testimonials: Mention positive customer reviews of carted items subtly to reinforce the purchase decision.
• Use Urgency or Scarcity Elements: Highlight limited stock or a time-sensitive discount transparently to build trust without overwhelming the primary message.
• Segment Emails Based on Content: Differentiate clearly between transactional and marketing emails. If abandoned cart emails include promotional offers, apply stricter CAN-SPAM guidelines, such as a clear opt-out, accurate subject lines, and a physical address.
• Maintain Transparency in Data Collection: Clearly inform customers upfront about how their data will be used, whether following CCPA/CPRA or CAN-SPAM. A transparent privacy policy and clear communication at the point of data collection help prevent legal complications.
• Honor Opt-Out Requests Promptly: Ensure opt-out links are easy to find, and process any unsubscribe requests within the required 10-business-day timeframe under CAN-SPAM. This applies to both marketing and transactional emails, even though opt-out options aren’t always legally required for the latter.

How Blueprint Digital Can Help You Leverage Abandoned Cart Emails

Blueprint Digital offers a tailored approach to optimizing abandoned cart email strategies, helping businesses craft emails that drive conversions while staying compliant with regulations, Our team focuses on understanding your unique business needs, ensuring each email not only serves as a helpful reminder but also aligns with your overall marketing goals. Beyond email, Blueprint Digital also enhances marketing efforts through strategies in PPC, SEO, and paid social, creating a seamless approach that strengthens engagement across channels.

Looking to boost your email strategy and turn more carts into conversions? Let’s connect! Schedule a free campaign review, and we’ll explore ways to make your abandoned cart emails more effective and drive better results for your business. 

Get started with Blueprint Digital

By: Blueprint